How to Find and Choose a Good Renovation Contractor

For many homeowners, finding a reliable contractor is one of the most important steps in a renovation project. It can be tempting to choose the first contractor available, but taking the time to compare several options can lessen the risk of unpleasant surprises.

Before committing, check the contractor's experience, licences, references, insurance, and the accuracy of their quote. Below are the key criteria to consider when looking for a contractor who is right for your project and making a more informed decision.

How to Find a Reliable Renovation Contractor for Your Project

Source: Deposit Photo

Recommendations and References

Has a friend or family member recently had work done on their home? Start by asking people you know for recommendations. If they feel comfortable recommending someone, their experience can give you valuable insight. If no one in your circle has worked with a renovation professional in the last year or so, keep looking.

You can also ask professionals you trust and have worked with in the past, such as real estate brokers, lawyers, bankers, or financial planners. They may be able to recommend contractors or companies they have had positive experiences with.

If someone you know refers you to a contractor, look through our practical guide before signing a contract.

Be Patient and Compare Several Contractors

Qualified contractors are often in high demand and may already have a busy schedule, so you may need to wait. However, a readily available contractor does not mean that they are any less qualified.

If you can schedule an appointment right away, pay attention to how reliable they are throughout the process. For example, if a contractor says they will call you back and repeatedly fails to do so, this may be a warning sign about their communication and reliability.

If you want a contractor who follows through on commitments, pay attention to how consistently they communicate with you. How many contractors should you meet? It is generally a good idea to obtain several quotes, with three being a useful number for comparison. Carefully compare quotes that fall within a similar price range and try to understand any major differences before making your decision.

Higher prices may reflect the contractor's experience, the materials used, or current market rates. A significantly lower price may sometimes indicate that certain work, materials, or costs have not been included, so make sure you understand exactly what each quote covers.

First Impression of the Contractor

Online reviews can sometimes be difficult to evaluate. It is not always easy to know whether comments posted on Google, Facebook, or other review platforms accurately reflect the contractor's work. Avoid signing a contract based on reviews alone, even if a contractor has excellent online reviews. A direct conversation is important. Start with a phone call to establish a more personal line of communication.

Ask several questions and pay attention to the answers. Start with the basics: Does your project fall within the services they provide? Can they provide references from past clients? Are they currently working on other projects? Once you're comfortable with their answers, schedule an in-person meeting.

A good contractor should make you feel confident in their renovation experience and knowledge. However, do not let a strong personality influence your decision. Focus on the facts and compare each contractor using the same criteria.

For more information, check out our article: Why Hire a General Contractor for Your Renovation Project?

What Questions Should You Ask Before Hiring a Contractor?

Source: Deposit Photo

Before hiring a contractor, assess their experience, how they work, and the project conditions. Here are some useful questions to ask:

• How long have you been in business?

• Have you completed projects similar to mine?

• Do you hold the licences required for this work?

• Do you have valid liability insurance?

• Do you work with your own crew or subcontractors?

• Can you provide references or examples of recent projects?

• What timeline do you expect for the work?

• What deposit do you require?

• How will the payments be scheduled?

• What warranties do you offer on the work?

• Do you provide a detailed written quote and contract?

Verify Licences, Insurance, and References

Source: Deposit Photo

Before meeting with contractors, check whether they hold any licences, certifications, or registrations required for the type of work being carried out in your province or municipality.

In Quebec, you can check with the Régie du Bâtiment du Québec to determine whether the contractor's licence is valid, when a licence is required, and consult the Registraire des entreprises to confirm that the business is properly registered.

In Quebec, do not simply check whether the contractor holds a valid RBQ licence. Make sure the subcategories listed on the licence correspond to the work you want to have completed. These subcategories determine the types of work the contractor is authorized to perform. You should also verify that the contractor has adequate liability insurance to provide greater protection in the event of damage during the project.

If you are still unsure about a contractor's reliability, check with the consumer protection authority in your province. In Quebec, you can consult the Office de la Protection du Consommateur to determine whether complaints have been filed against the contractor.

It is also worth checking available legal records. In Quebec, the Société Québécoise d’Information Juridique provides access to judgments issued by different courts in the province. Searching the contractor's name can help you determine whether they have previously been involved in legal proceedings with clients and how those cases were resolved.

Assess Communication and Customer Service

When you hire a contractor, you are the client. Before, during, and after the work, you may have questions, requests, or concerns about your renovation project. Even when they are busy, your contractor should respond to calls or messages within a reasonable amount of time. Good customer service keeps you informed and ensures that questions are addressed throughout the project.

The contractor should also remain available after the work is completed to provide after-sales service. Sometimes homeowners notice problems or omissions after the project is finished. A reliable contractor should be willing to return to the property to assess the situation. You can ask former clients about their experience with the contractor's after-sales service.

For more information, check out our article: What to Do When a Contractor Requests Payment Before the Work Is Completed.

Check Their Ability to Meet Deadlines

Source: Deposit Photo

This can have a major impact on whether your renovation project runs smoothly. An overbooked contractor may not be able to give your project the attention it requires or may rush the work to move on to the next job. A good contractor may have several projects underway, but they should still be able to manage their workload and establish a realistic schedule for your project.

Compare Quotes and Establish Payment Terms

Source: Deposit Photo

Ideally, obtain written quotes from three contractors so you can compare not only prices but also the scope of work, proposed materials, and timeline. Do not automatically choose the lowest quote: a significant difference in price may be related to the materials, experience, or work that is not included.

What a Contractor Quote Should Include

A detailed quote makes it easier to compare contractors and reduces the risk of misunderstandings during the project. It should clearly identify the nature of the project, the work included, the materials to be used, and the associated costs.

Ideally, the quote should include:

• A detailed description of the work

• The materials, products, and equipment to be used

• Labour and material costs

• Applicable taxes

• Estimated start and completion dates

• Payment terms and schedule

• Work or expenses that are not included in the price

• Warranties provided

• The contractor's contact information and licence number, where required

When comparing several quotes, make sure they cover the same scope of work. A less expensive quote may be more appealing, but some materials, steps, or additional costs may simply have been excluded.

Payment Terms and Contract

Whenever possible, avoid paying a large deposit before work begins. For projects carried out over several stages, it is generally preferable to schedule payments according to work progress.

In Quebec, the Office de la Protection du Consommateur indicates that a final payment representing approximately 10% to 15% of the total cost may be made once the work has been completed and deemed satisfactory. Payment and deposit rules may differ elsewhere in Canada, so check the consumer protection requirements that apply in your province.

The contract should also specify the total cost, the work and materials included, the project dates, required licences and permits, liability insurance, and the procedure to follow if additional work becomes necessary.

Recognizing the Red Flags in a Contractor

Certain behaviours should make you cautious before signing a contract. A reliable contractor should be transparent about pricing, qualifications, timelines, and the scope of work.

Here are some warning signs to watch for:

• They refuse to provide a written quote or contract

• They ask for a very large deposit before work begins

• They pressure you to sign quickly

• They refuse to provide references or examples of previous projects

• Their licences or insurance cannot be verified

• Their price is significantly lower than other quotes without a clear explanation

• The quote is vague or does not specify the materials and work included

• They are difficult to reach or avoid answering certain questions

• They propose additional work without explaining why it is necessary or how much it will cost

• They request unusual payments or payment methods that are difficult to trace

One of these warning signs does not necessarily mean that a contractor is unreliable. However, if several red flags appear, it is generally better to continue your search and compare other professionals before making a commitment.

Using a Contractor Referral Service

Source: RenoQuotes

A contractor referral service can simplify your search by quickly connecting you with professionals who match your project. With RenoQuotes, simply describe the work you need done in the project form to be connected with contractors in your area.

Your project may be sent to up to three contractors, allowing you to compare multiple quotes without having to contact several companies yourself. Contractors who join our network go through a screening process that includes checks of their licences and reputation.

Follow Up During the Project

Choosing a reliable contractor does not mean you should stop monitoring the project once the contract is signed. Maintain regular communication with the contractor and check the progress at key stages of the project. This can help you identify delays, project changes, or potential budget overruns early.

When a change becomes necessary, agree on the additional work and its cost before it is carried out. The contract should also require the contractor to obtain your approval before completing work that was not originally included.

Choose the Best Contractor to Start Your Project Off Right

Finding a good contractor requires some research, but this step can make a significant difference in how smoothly your project runs. Take some time to verify their licences, references, and insurance, compare several quotes, and ask questions before signing a contract.

Once you have made up your mind, maintain regular contact throughout the project and make sure any changes are clearly documented. This will help you avoid unpleasant surprises and complete your renovation project under better conditions.

Would you like to compare contractors for your renovation project? RenoQuotes can connect you with up to three contractors in your area so you can compare their quotes free of charge.

For more information about how our services work, check out our FAQ page.