blog-banner

Are you looking for a contractor?

Submit our quick form and get quotes now!

Table of Contents

Flooring

6 min read

What are pyrite and pyrrhotite and how do you deal with them?

Flooring

6 min read

What are pyrite and pyrrhotite and how do you deal with them?

FlooringWhat are pyrite and pyrrhotite and how do you deal with them?

Pyrite is an iron sulphide, known as “fool’s gold” whose crystallization shimmers with gilded reflections. If the brilliance of this worthless mineral deceived gold prospectors of their time, its oxidization when in contact with moisture and oxygen, producing sulfuric acid, stirs up a bitterness in many owners today. The presence of pyrite or of pyrrhotite underneath a foundation may cause the slab of concrete of the house to rise and crack.

In some parts of Quebec and the United States, the problem is so widespread that citizen rallies have been organized so that people who are affected can come together to find solutions and put pressure on governments to receive help.

The difference between pyrite and pyrrhotite

Before we dig deeper into the subject, it is important to determine the difference between pyrite and pyrrhotite that are sometimes confused. Here are the definitions presented on the Régie du Bâtiment du Québec website:

Pyrite is a mineral which is found in stone and produces sulfuric acid when it oxidizes upon contact with humidity and oxygen. When this phenomenon occurs under foundations, it can cause the heaving and cracking of the concrete slab.

Pyrrhotite is a mineral species composed of iron sulfide and is of a bronze yellow color, blackening when exposed to air. When it crystallizes in blades, pyrrhotite can produce cracks in the concrete structures."

Source: R.B.Q.

Why is pyrite or pyrrhotite present under the house?

When excavating a piece of land to pour the concrete foundations of a dwelling, the area is not totally flat. This is why we spread the fill, a mass of material used to elevate the ground. Except for using the fill commonly known as“DB certificate”, it is possible that this material contains the particles from harmful minerals.

If the pyrite oxidizes upon contact with moisture, it forms gypsum crystals which increase the volume of the fill. “It’s like a ball of dough in the oven. It expands in every direction”, illustrates Guy Forest founder of Multitest in La Presse of September 13, 2014. 

Under the garage, pyrite pushes upwards and extends towards the sides, which can damage the foundations of the house. 

The quality of the fill isn’t uniquely determined by the presence or absence of these two minerals in the material. Certain types of stone such as clay shales react more to the oxidization of iron sulphate. When in contact with moisture and oxygen, the swelling of pyrite is amplified by these types of stones.

How to check for pyrite?  

In the case of building a new home, you must ensure the fill being used is DB certified. According to the Association des consommateurs pour la qualité dans la construction (ACQC), the CTQ-M100 standard, which aims at certifying the non-inflating quality of fills used in construction, is not mandatory. 

“The use remains on a voluntary basis. Unfortunately, we still see contractors who put a part of the uncertified fill just to save a dollar or two a ton” deplored Guy Forest, founder of Multitest in La Presse of September 13, 2014.

In the case of a buyback or in case you have doubts if your property is more than 10 years old, you can have the fill of your house and garage checked. The standardized tests determine the type of stone and its Petrographic Index Swelling Potential (PEPI). In the case of swelling or cracks, you can order a chemical analysis of the fill which will indicate if the pyrite has completed its reaction.

According to the ACQC, there is no method for neutralizing the effect of oxidation. The best way to get rid of pyrite problems is to break the concrete slab, remove all the fill and concrete debris and make a new slab on good quality fill afterwards.  Demolishing a slab in the garage and replacing its fill is less costly than carrying out the same operation in the basement.

Take into consideration that the basement area is larger than that of the garage. In addition, access to excavation equipment is much more difficult. This work requires the demolition and reconstruction of the existing partitions. Before embarking on this costly project, make sure to assess the extent of the damage well.  

Follow the progression of the swelling by taking note of the date and length of the crack, measure the fracture on one side or the other of the crumbling crack. Make a sketch or take pictures of the issues for proof of swelling when consulting an expert.

If there is pyrite in your home...

According to the ACQC, sellers who get an appraisal to determine the potential for swelling of the fill may have to deal with the presence of pyrite. If so, the value of the house could decrease even if the slab can remain intact. On the other hand, if you sell a house without mentioning the presence of pyrite, you may receive a formal notice 3, 5, 10 or even 30 years down the line. 

Selling without a legal warranty exempts you from these responsibilities. While the warranty is legal, the warranty plan for new residential buildings expires 5 years after you take possession of your home.

The government of Quebec has put in place a program designed to help owners of residential buildings damaged by pyrite to help the homeowners to make the necessary adjustments. The government of Quebec assumes 62.5% of the financial assistance granted, the government of Canada contributes 25%, and municipalities are invited to participate by contributing up to 12.5%. Some municipalities also offer aid. For more information, consult the ACQC guide “Pyrite and your house”.

Although the problem can begin under the garage, pushing upwards and extending to the sides and damaging the foundation of the house, the government program only applies to the residential part of the building. Therefore, a garage is not eligible, considered a space without a residential function.

Is pyrite harmful to your health?

Unlike asbestos and the old lead pipes that are being removed from homes, pyrite and pyrrhotite are not harmful to your health. The quantities of sulfuric acid are too negligible to cause health problems, according to the Monteregie Department of Public Health. 

However, cracks in the slab or foundation’s walls could increase the moisture content in the basement leading to the developing of moulds that can be detrimental to one’s health.

Get 3 renovation quotes to address problems related to pyrite in your house

RenoQuotes.com will put you in contact with 3 reliable contractors to get quotes to counter pyrite swelling. Fill in the form on our homepage (it only takes a few minutes), and you will receive quotes from trusted professionals.

Dial 1-844 828-1588 to speak with one of our customer service representatives

Get 3 free quotes for your project!

Submit a project and get 3 free quotes!


Last modified 2023-11-07

List of sources


Get 3 free quotes for your project!

Submit a project and get 3 free quotes!

Looking for something else?


Table of contents


Get 3 free quotes for your project!

Submit a project and get 3 free quotes!

Are you a contractor?

Join our network and receive real leads!

Download the price guide for renovations

We’ll be emailing you the latest market price guide for renovations.



Related articles

The latest industry news, interviews, technologies, and resources.

4 min read

RenoQuotes.com • 07 Nov 2023

Five Useful Home Renovation Tips

Since home renovations can either be a great experience or a real nightmare, here are 5 useful renovation tips that will help you complete your project to obtain the best possible results.

5 min read

RenoQuotes.com • 05 Dec 2023

How to Maintain a Pergola

A pergola is a great alternative to a traditional patio umbrella. Not only does this sunshade provide a more aesthetic appeal compared to the latter, but it also offers a wide range of options in terms of materials and sizes. On top of that, it doubles as a permanent patio lounge area, while still shielding you from the elements. Despite being exposed to Canada's harsh East Coast climate and other elements, preserving its condition for many years to come requires meticulous care and maintenance.

7 min read

N/A • 08 May 2024

The Average Cost of Various Landscaping Projects

With spring around the corner, homeowners tend to look over their yards more often than not and compare them with that of their neighbours, which might lead one to notice their sad state. Thus, it may be a good idea to begin drawing up the list (starting with leaf removal) of all the projects that must be carried out to restore a yard to its former glory.

5 min read

Léa Plourde-Archer • 07 Nov 2023

Class Action Lawsuit Against Kitec

Have you heard of Kitec? This plumbing system made by IPEX in the late nineties has been gathering press as of late, and not for the right reasons!

10 min read

RenoQuotes.com • 07 Nov 2023

How ESG Criteria Shape the Construction Industry

In Canada, the construction industry is facing numerous challenges, especially regarding corporate social responsibility (CSR). 


Looking for a contractor?

Submit a project and get 3 free quotes now!