The Great White Roof Debate

By Cynthia Pigeon

Updated on November 7, 2023

To limit the creation of urban heat islands, white roofs have become increasingly popular and are the subject of much media attention. Praised by some and questioned by others, there is much debate about the real benefits of white roofs. Here is a summary of the information reported by the two main parties involved.

White Roofs

White roofs according to Association des maîtres couvreurs du Québec (AMCQ)

According to the AMCQ, white roofs are not linked to the decreasing presence of heat islands. In fact, they appear to have the unfortunate consequence of increasing heating costs. The rationale behind this statement is that in a cold climate, such as the one experienced in Quebec, a white roof forces you to start heating much earlier in the fall and for an extended period of time in the spring.

While for some, the motive behind a white roof is to benefit from high energy efficiency, this can also be a letdown. The AMCQ argues that prioritizing good attic insulation is a far better idea, as 30% of the heat is lost through the attic.

Additional drawbacks include the possibility of a white roof soiling over time, to the point of turning gray. As a result, it would lose 30 to 60% of its solar reflectance index. According to an article published on the CORPIQ website, Michel Paré, director of development at AMCQ, stated: "We're talking about a maximum five-year capacity to absorb the sun's rays. After that, we observe the same reflective results as with a grey roof (...)”.

Hence, the questionability of a white roof’s potential to limit heat accumulation. Following this statement, the AMCQ also tried to mitigate the adverse perception of asphalt roofs coated with gravel in relation to the formation of heat islands. As a matter of fact, their heat mass has been proven not sufficient enough to generate heat for more than an hour after sunset.

white roof_the great white roof debate

Photo: Flickr Walmart

Can White Roofs Not Be Cleaned?

Naturally, the next logical thought process is to think about cleaning the roof covering. However, the problem with this is that it can be a risky venture with most of the materials typically used in white roofs. After all, elastomeric membranes degrade over time, and their coating will be affected when cleaned. Furthermore, pure white membranes are solely obtained at an extra cost.

Although white PVC or thermoplastic membranes are easier to clean, they will nonetheless lose their colour with time. Note that cleaning these materials will require professional expertise and represent an additional expense. And, the costs can be considerable as well as the fact that the overall practice can have a negative impact on the environment.

EcoHome: Insight Regarding White Roofs

However, EcoHome supports AMCQ's position regarding heating costs being higher during the fall but still recognizes that white roofs allow for a more comfortable temperature to be maintained in the summer as well as reduce air conditioning costs.

The association also states that membranes used to manufacture white roofs are much thinner than asphalt roofs, which minimizes their environmental impact.

Emmanuel Cosgrove, director of the association, concurs with the AMCQ on the consequences of white roof coverings soiling easily. He also maintains that white membranes will soil within two years to the point that their solar reflectance will be greatly affected.  

Despite the conflicting concerns outlined in this article, if you are interested in having a white roof installed, do not hesitate to contact a contractor who specializes in roofing membranes. They will have the expertise and knowledge to provide you with alternative perspectives on the matter. 

Are you looking for more information about roofing? Check out our Roof Renovation Guide

Cover photo: Flickr

Get 3 renovation quotes for your roofing project

RenoQuotes.com will put you in contact with 3 reliable contractors for your roofing renovation project. Fill in the form on our homepage (it only takes a few minutes), and you will receive quotes from trusted professionals.

Dial 1-844 828-1588 to speak with one of our customer service representatives.


Get 3 free quotes for your project!

Submit a project and get 3 free quotes!

Looking for something else?

Get 3 free quotes for your project!

Submit a project and get 3 free quotes!

Are you a contractor?

Join our network and receive real leads!

Download the price guide for renovations

We’ll be emailing you the latest market price guide for renovations.



Related articles

The latest industry news, interviews, technologies, and resources.

6 min read

Editorial Team

01 Aug 2024

Price of Fibre Cement Siding and Installation Guide

Are you considering installing fibre cement siding during your next renovation project? While the motivational factors behind such an undertaking are likely plenty, you may still be hoping to get pertinent information about the cost of installing such a siding to make a well-informed decision. 

Exterior renovations
8 min read

Editorial Team

05 Nov 2024

Hiring a Contractor - How to Ensure They're the Right Fit

For many, one of the most challenging aspects of a home improvement project is finding the right contractor to carry out the job. Avoid making a deal with the first available Joe with the sole purpose of saving both money and time, given that it could lead to problems down the line. If you’re wondering how to hire the right person, you’ve come to the right place!

Exterior renovations
5 min read

Editorial Team

07 Nov 2023

15 Signs Your Home Needs to be Renovated

When we purchase our first home, everything seems perfect. Of course, over time you live there, grow your family and build a cocoon to call your own. Over the years, your home evolves with you, and while it may be subtle, it can age quickly. 

Exterior renovations
9 min read

Editorial Team

09 Sep 2024

Baseboard Heaters: A Myriad of Options for Your Needs

The term “electric baseboard heater” hits just the same as "oversized sweater." It’s warm and comfortable and brings solace right when the winter cold storms in.

Electricity and lighting
5 min read

Cynthia Pigeon

05 Dec 2023

What Are the Different Types of Window Shutters?

Are your windows in need of new coverings or a spiffy new look? If you are not a blind- or curtain-enthusiast, why not opt for shutters? It is not always the most obvious option, however, shutters can revamp your windows as well as allow for great sightlines. 


Looking for a contractor?

Submit a project and get 3 free quotes now!